The windmills of my mind

As regular readers will know, I am no great fan of Alba Party. But I have to admit that I’m tending towards Kenny MacAskill’s perspective on this much trumpeted “wind boom” (Scotland set for ‘transformational’ wind boom ‘like black gold rush’). Not least because it is being so fervently trumpeted. I get a strong sense of Nicola Sturgeon’s unquestionable turd-polishing skills being called upon. That may just be my natural cynicism, of course. Just as Kenny MacAskill’s criticism may just be opposition for its own sake. Of one thing I’m sure, however, and that is that it’s more complicated than it is being made to look. It’s unlikely to be the unalloyed boon as proclaimed by the First Minister. By the same token, it’s probably not the unforgivable sell-out some suppose it to be. There will be benefits. There will be costs. Who reaps the benefits and who bears the costs is unknowable other than in a very narrow sense and over the very short term. But with the little information we have and the benefit of experience we can get an initial feel for the thing. And I feel much as Kenny MacAskill does.

It looks like the Scottish Government have [sic] surrendered vast chunks of the North Sea wind resource for a relative pittance just as Westminster gave away Scotland’s oil in the 1970s.

Instead of a one off payment of under £700m there should be annual payments. Instead of Scottish resources being just handed over to international investment companies there should be a public stake in every single field.

That sounds only sensible. But one would need far more knowledge of the energy sector than I possess to make a truly informed judgement. Like most people, I’ll look at what the ‘experts’ say and maybe read a couple of Wikipedia articles and make a provisional judgement on that basis. My initial impression is that it’s not such a good deal for the people of Scotland. I like the idea of annual payments and a public stake. Development of renewable sources of energy is a long-term project. It would seem only sensible that a long-term benefit to the people of Scotland should be secured from the outset. I’m seeing no sign of that.

Jobs! Jobs! Jobs! It sometimes seems there’s no limit to what can be justified by the claim that it will bring jobs. I suppose it ‘naturally’ follows that once the product of labour and the the labour itself have been commodified then the role of labourer should also be turned into something that must be purchased. Capital ‘owns’ the jobs. Governments buy jobs with subsidies and deregulation. Individuals buy jobs with subsidies in the form of low wages and poor conditions. And it doesn’t matter how good you think your working conditions are or how well you suppose you’re remunerated, it is always the case that you could do better in all regards if you weren’t in the position of having to trade time, sweat and personal dignity for a job before you even start to make a living.

When I read of deals such as the auctioning of opportunities to exploit our nation’s natural resources I can’t help but note how well protected from the vagaries of ‘The Market’ private interests tend to be; and how precarious is the portion which accrues to the public purse or the worker’s wage-packet. Apparently, this is just how it is. It’s nobody’s fault. It’s just the way things work. At which point I’m prompted to wonder why, if this is the case, we so richly reward those who claim to be in control of the way things work.

I suppose it’s my own fault for thinking too much. Or at all. Maybe I should just cheer along with Nicola Sturgeon and leave it at that.

If you find these articles interesting please consider a small donation to help support this site and my other activities on behalf of Scotland’s cause.


6 thoughts on “The windmills of my mind

  1. What happened to the Scottish Government’s promise in 2017 that “We are committed to delivering, in partnership with local authorities, a public energy company offering retail energy supply by the end of this current Parliament (March 2021).”? [See

    There is so much hot air coming out of the Scottish Government in terms of ‘pledges’ and ‘promises’ that they threaten any benefits accruing to the environment from the new green energy sources.

    Liked by 4 people

  2. 1) Recommend reading from Robin McAlpine:

    2) Marianna Mazzucato – is one of the Scottish Government economic advisors (perhaps not keen (unless) on Indy) – but have been reading her books for a while and I very much doubt she would see Scotwind as other than a MAJOR opportunity lost. Flavour of her thinking here:

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Mike.

      Yeah I read that yesterday, McAlpine appears to know something of what’s going on by that article, one point stipulated by the foreign power companies was that the construction of the wind turbines didn’t happen in Scotland.

      It is yet again worth comparing this situation with the way that Norway developed its oil and gas sector in public ownership capturing the profit for Norwegian citizens, not so with Scotland. Interestingly the British media now claiming that Scotland will produce at least five times the energy that it needs, meanwhile a third of Scots are in fuel poverty with more set to follow in April with the huge price rises in fuel on the way.


  3. Sturgeon’s gaze is now so narrow that she didn’t even have the aptitude to wangle out a power deal from the big power companies to run a state owned energy company to help Scots meet their electricity needs at a lower cost.

    Mind you she lauded her previous attempt at a state ran energy firm Our Power of which I was a convinced customer that it was the way forward, only for it to fold, Sturgeon talks a good game but that all in my opinion.

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.