Deep failure

Everything Joanna Cherry says about British Labour and Sir Keir Starmer is correct. But pointing out the utter uselessness of British Labour and its leader does seem to be stating the obvious. We rather take it for granted now that the supposed main opposition party will offer no meaningful opposition whatever to a regime which arguably is more in need of effective opposition than any in living memory. And I do not exclude Thatcher from that. I’m hardly the one to sing the praises of the Batty Baroness, but at least in her day the Tories made some effort to be discreet about their corrupt practices. Thatcher’s policies may have been anathema to anyone with a social conscience, but they were worked-out policies. What she planned was despicable. But at least it was planned.

We may find the ‘old order’ abhorrent. But at least it is order of a kind. With Boris Johnson, all is disorder. Everything seems disjointed, makeshift and slapdash. This is the very antithesis of the ‘joined-up government’ we’re forever being promised. It’s a mess.

And yet if there was a UK general election tomorrow it is highly likely that the British Conservative party would be returned to power – largely on the back of votes that once would have gone to British Labour. That is the measure of British Labour’s failure. That is the measure of the failure of the entire British political system. It’s not just that the British government resembles a teetering pile of Jenga bricks. It’s that the main opposition is unable to muster the nudge that would topple it. The system’s own corrective is completely ineffective. This isn’t just failure. It’s deep failure.

There is, however, a big difference between failing and falling. The idea commonly voiced on social media, that the manifest failures of the British political system signal its imminent collapse is naïve. One of the main reasons Sir Keir Starmer is incapable of delivering a knockout blow to Boris Johnson is that he doesn’t want to. British Labour’s internal strife may have undermined its ability to be an effective opposition. The polls may make the prospect of an election uninviting. But there is also a profound reluctance to do anything that might jeopardise the system itself. British Labour is as much a part of the structures of power, privilege and patronage which define the British state as the Tories. Those structures must be preserved at any cost.

British Labour is useless as an official opposition not least because what is perceived to be at stake is more than just a spell in government. British Labour won’t fully exploit revelations about corruption and criminal incompetence within the British government for the same reason they won’t tolerate the people of Scotland exercising our right of self-determination. Both represent threats to those structures of power, privilege and patronage which are as necessary for British Labour as for their Tory dancing partners.

. In a recent article for the White Rose Rising blog I wrote,

The present constitutional arrangement is flawed not only due to the asymmetry of power enshrined in the Union but because of the imbalance of power entrenched in the British political system. For change to happen; for there to be even the possibility of a more satisfactory distribution of political power the existing system must first be broken and the fragments vigorously shaken. UK elects neither break nor shake. They leave the structures of power, privilege and patronage intact with no more than a trivial shifting around of the pieces.

Ending the Union is a revolutionary act. Restoring Scotland’s independence is a revolutionary act.

A revolutionary act

British Labour is not a revolutionary party. It’s not even a radical party. It’s barely a socialist party in anything but name. British Labour is not going risk breaking or even shaking the system within which it is embedded and with which it has a symbiotic relationship. British Labour won’t even deal with the affront to democracy that is the British House of Lords for exactly the same reason.

The headline on Joann Cherry’s column asks Will Boris Johnson block indyref2 plans with a General Election? The answer to that question is affirmative. If that’s what it takes, he won’t hesitate. He certainly won’t hesitate on account of fear of Her Majesty’s Loyal Opposition. He knows he can rely absolutely on British Labour’s loyalty to the system epitomised by the monarchy. British Labour seems to have accepted that the British state is a Tory state where they get to have a spell in office once in a while but are otherwise only there to soak up the votes which might otherwise go to a radical or even a revolutionary party.

There was a time when the SNP had the potential to be that revolutionary party. Now, it seems not.

In closing, Joanna Cherry says,

My fear is that Johnson, or indeed a successor such as Sunak, will engineer another General Election at a time of his choosing to […] stymie the chances of holding a second indyref in 2023. Contingency plans are required.

My fear is that not only is Nicola Sturgeon not making plans for such a scenario, she is actually counting on it to justify further delay in confronting the constitutional issue.



If you find these articles interesting please consider a small donation to help support this site and my other activities on behalf of Scotland’s independence movement.

Donate with PayPal

6 thoughts on “Deep failure

  1. There are currently 2 main blockages to ending the Union:

    The secondary obstacle is past, present and future incumbents of 10 Downing Street, their government and the system they represent.

    The primary obstacle is the current incumbent of Bute House and her increasingly colonial Scottish administration.

    Liked by 3 people

  2. “… My fear is that not only is Nicola Sturgeon not making plans for such a scenario, she is actually counting on it to justify further delay in confronting the constitutional issue… ”

    In my opinion, your fear is entirely justified, Peter. I understand what you mean when you say the other (Unionist) parties are ‘British’: of course they are; however, in their essence, they are English parties, and the layer of Britishness is just that – a layer over their core Englishness. It is maddening for many Scots that Labour, the party founded in Scotland on principles of service to the poorest and the most alienated from power, metamorphosed very early in its existence into the party of opposition in England, abandoning both its birthplace and its core principles. Those are the very reasons that I have always felt unable to vote Labour although, being on the nationalist left, I, personally, have always felt a strong affinity with its shadow self, the Scottish, working-class Labour Party which was avowedly in favour of home rule for Scotland.

    The SNP has followed suit and abandoned its raison d’etre. What happens to people when they achieve power, or seek to achieve power, that they must always abandon the very core principles that nurtured them? It is as if a malignant worm has burrowed its way into their brains and their spines, infecting them with malaise and torpor leading to inaction and stasis. They become part of the problem.

    Liked by 4 people

  3. Once more the nail hits the head. I always had the thought that Mrs Thatcher believed in what she was doing and was only doing it ‘for our own good’ because we didn’t know any better!

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Surely is any new UK General Election was called within this timeframe, SNP policy should be that a simple majority of SNPs will be the end of the Union?
    That once was the policy, and it should go back to it.
    But of course, we would rather we had out Independence, before then!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. You know things are in a terminally bad way when Thatcher and her government appear like saints with competence, compassion and integrity, compared to the current Prime Minister of the UK and his Government.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.