Playing their game

Tommy Sheppard is right. The British government’s refusal to release the results of its polling on attitudes to the Union and Scottish independence certainly does beg the question, what is it they’re trying to hide? But we shouldn’t restrict ourselves to the most obvious questions, or the first query that occurs to us. We might well ask why they are trying to hide it.

The reasons for hiding something are not necessarily connected to the nature of the thing being hidden in any direct or obvious way. The act of hiding may be more significant than what is being hidden. It is certainly worth exploring what the motives may be.

The obvious conclusion is that the thing being concealed is potentially embarrassing. In this particular instance, it is only natural to assume that the polling must undermine the British government’s position on the Union. It would seem likely that the results show less support for the Union than British Nationalists would like and/or more support for independence than they are prepared to acknowledge.

But less support for the Union doesn’t have to mean a dramatic collapse. And more support for independence needn’t mean a dramatic surge. In fact, polling already in the public domain suggests the split is still hovering around 50%. I always thought the fuss which greeted a recent poll show 52% for independence was rather overdone, given that the margin of error is commonly +/-3%. Of course, any majority for independence is welcome news for some of us – even if it is conditional and with the ‘don’t knows’ stripped out. And such numbers would are certainly problematic for British Nationalists who are still trying to convince the public that independence is a ‘fringe’ issue in Scotland.

There being no reason to suppose the British government’s secret polling might be an outlier, I am prompted to wonder why they are so desperate to keep it hidden. It could be that they are simply defending the convention that advice sought or provided to the government is confidential. But even taking this very sensible principle into account, the case for a FoI exemption seems weak. Which makes their apparent determination to take it all the way even more curious. What might explain this apparently pointless obduracy?

Here’s a thought! Suppose the polling results are actually quite dull. Suppose they show, not a big swing to Yes, but just a run-of-the-mill 52/48 split in favour of the Union. Suppose the information is being hidden solely because the British government knows that the SNP will make a big deal of it only to be left looking a bit foolish when the information is finally released.

Devious? Indeed it is. Far-fetched? Well, I started out thinking so. The original idea was to use this to illustrate the need to always ask the awkward questions and never settle for the obvious answers. The ending I had planned dismissed the notion of such Machiavellian shenanigans. But, now that I’m here, I’m not so sure. The way British politics is at the moment it doesn’t seem safe to discount any silliness.

The real lesson here may be for Tommy Sheppard and other SNP politicians. Perhaps they need to be wary of reacting in predictable ways to the antics of the British political elite. With all due respect to Tommy, he could be following a script written by his opponents. He is playing their game. Following their rules. It might be worth considering more nuanced tactics.

If you find these articles interesting please consider a small donation to help support this site and my other activities on behalf of Scotland’s independence movement.

Donate with PayPalDonate with Pingit

6 thoughts on “Playing their game

  1. Thought provoking as usual.
    Only thought I had was that I felt it was perhaps revealing that it was very soon after the poll that Theresa May came to Scotland, supposedly to strengthen the Union. She was also admitting that she had paid too little attention to that and was advising her successor to pay more heed.
    Of course we now know that Boris’s idea of more heed is a different thing altogether.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. The secret of good interrogation is to know the answers to the questions you ask. I would hope that this is how Tommy Sheppard is approaching this.


    1. If he had information about the poll it’s highly unlikely he’d be the only one. And if others had that information it would have been leaked by now.


      1. That still leaves the question open and cutting both ways. Because if the unionist side had the info and it was in their favour, it would have leaked by now.

        Looking at how the SNP took the single poll showing a majority in favour of Indy not quite outrunning the margin of error, I would say that either they were OTT or it just confirms something they already know, either by private polling or by leak of the government poll. So even if Tommy Sheppard does not have the UK Government polling results, he probably feels he has a good poker hand for using this to embarrass the UK Government.

        Plus, just to be utterly cynical, if you wanted the polling results, you could commission the UK Goverment’s pollster for a similar survey and expect results which are consistent and show the passage of time. Would any pollster want conflicting sets of results out there under their name? Only if there were some explanation. Now if the SNP went down that road, and Tommy were embarrassed about what the UK government ultimately released, assuming that Tommy had a good set of results in his back pocket from a slightly later date, it would be straightforward to then release the new results and say “Look how things are changing!”


  3. If the UK Government DOES have something to hide, could it be not so much the results of the polling as the questions? Perhaps part of the exercise involved sounding out public opinion on curtailing the powers of the Scottish Parliament/suspending or abolishing it/direct rule from Westminster?

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.